Vintry & Mercer HotelNumber 1 on our UK dog-friendly hotels list.Check pricesOur notesOur method
How We Choose
How a stay gets onto a ChooseMyHotel list, how the order is decided, and what Checked means.
Nobody should lose a weekend to a surprise that was in the small print.
ChooseMyHotel exists for one reason. Booking sites list everything and rate most of it Superb, and the details that decide whether a stay works for you are rarely there: what the dog costs, whether the hot tub is yours or shared with the whole park, what the spa actually contains. We pick fewer places and show those details, or say plainly that we do not know them yet.
1. We look broadly
Every list starts from every bookable stay we can find for that theme and place: hotels, B&Bs, pubs with rooms, lodges, glamping and, where the search asks for them, cottages. The largest single pool behind one of our lists holds 22,645 places.
2. Few make the cut
A stay needs a high guest rating sustained over enough reviews. Lodges, cabins and cottages collect fewer reviews than hotels, so they need a higher score to qualify. On leisure themes such as dog-friendly, hot tub and spa, a list holds at most two chain properties. National lists stop at 30 stays and regional ones at 20. A place list goes live only with at least six stays we would book; below that, we would rather not publish it.
139 lists · 2,850 stays shortlisted
3. The ChooseScore
Within a list, stays are ordered by a published formula. Every weight is here, so you can check our order.
-
Guest rating 40%
The score guests give on the booking site, out of 10.
-
Review volume 20%
More reviews make a score more reliable. The effect stops growing at 2,000 reviews, so big city chains do not win on volume alone.
-
Fit with the theme 20%
Full weight once the property confirms the detail that matters (the dog fee, the private hot tub). Half weight while it is listing data only.
-
Character 10%
Independent places score full; chain properties score less.
-
Editors' judgement 10%
What we know that a number cannot show, recorded with a reason.
An editor can fix a position by hand. When that happens, the reason is recorded with the change.
4. The small print, checked
For each theme we ask the property the questions that decide a booking, by email or phone, and record who confirmed what and when. A detail marked Checked carries that date. After twelve months without a fresh confirmation it loses the label again.
- Checked + date Confirmed by the property, dated.
- No label What the listing says. Not confirmed by us.
- - Not in any source we trust. We never guess it.
Where we are today: zero of the 2,850 stays on our lists are Checked. Every other card shows listing details only, and our titles and descriptions never claim a check that has not happened.
Vintry & Mercer HotelNumber 1 on our UK dog-friendly hotels list.Check pricesOur notesThe small print
- Dogs
- Allowed, per the listing
- Dog fee
- -
- Dogs inside
- -
- Restaurant
- On site, per the listing
- Parking
- -
5. Why it made the cut, and the catch
Every stay gets one line on why it is there and one honest drawback, including the number one. Until an editor has written them, both come from the listing and the list itself: the rating and where it ranks, what the place offers that others here do not, and what is missing or unconfirmed.
Why it made the cut
Rated 9.4 from 2,219 guest reviews; with a restaurant listed.
The catch
Free parking is not listed; ask what parking costs before you drive.
6. Ratings are theirs, not ours
Guest ratings and review counts come from Booking.com and are always shown with that source. They are not a ChooseMyHotel score, and we do not mark them up as our own reviews.
7. No pay to rank
We earn money when you book through our Check prices links, through affiliate programmes such as Booking.com's. That commission never decides whether a stay is listed or where it ranks, and no property can pay for either. If we ever show a paid placement, it will sit in a separate block labelled Sponsored and will never carry a ChooseScore or a Checked label. Affiliate disclosure
8. Tell us when we are wrong
If a detail on a card is out of date, tell us. We look at every report within two working days. If a Small Print detail changes, the card says Corrected with the date.